Return to Play

Men playing tennis

Using a combination of validated subjective and objective measures is essential for reliably assessing an athlete’s readiness to return to sport after shoulder injury or surgery; this approach provides measurable, research-based criteria that help reduce re-injury risk and ensure a safe progression back to activity. Here are the most validated tests based on the current research for assessing return to sport.

By combining these elements and considering the demands of the specific sport, clinicians can make well-informed decisions and reduce the risk of re-injury, supporting a successful transition back to training and competition.

The Return to Sport objective measures are:

  • Western Ontario Shoulder Instability Index (WOSI)
  • ASH test
  • Closed Kinetic Chain Upper Extremity Stability Test (CKCUEST)
  • Posterior Shoulder Endurance Test (PSET)
  • External Rotation to Internal Rotation Ratio

Scroll down for further details on how to perform each test.


WOSI

The Western Ontario Shoulder Instability Index (WOSI) is a validated, patient-reported outcome measure designed specifically to assess quality of life and functional limitations in individuals with shoulder instability.

Structure

The WOSI consists of 21 items grouped into four domains:

  • Physical symptoms (10 items)
  • Sports/recreation/work (4 items)
  • Lifestyle (4 items)
  • Emotions (3 items)

Scoring

Each item is scored using a 100 mm visual analog scale (VAS), where 0 = no problem and 100 = worst possible problem.
The total score is the sum of all 21 items, ranging from 0 (best possible function) to 2100 (worst possible function).
The score can also be converted to a 0–100 scale for easier interpretation.

Percentage of normal function = 100- (total score divided by 21000 x 100)

Interpretation

  • Lower scores = better shoulder function and quality of life.
  • Higher scores = greater impairment due to shoulder instability.
  • Responsiveness and Minimal Important Change (MIC):
The WOSI can detect meaningful changes in shoulder function over time. The minimal important change (MIC) is about 14 points on a 0–100 scale, meaning a change greater than this is likely to be clinically significant.
  • Practical Considerations:
The WOSI takes about 10 minutes to complete, which is longer than some other shoulder outcome measures, but it is considered the preferred tool for assessing shoulder instability due to its specificity, validity, and responsiveness.

WOSI Questionnaire


ASH test

The Athletic Shoulder (ASH) Test is a recently developed tool designed to evaluate and track shoulder isometric strength in athletes throughout their recovery process. Introduced by Ashworth et al. in 2018, this innovative test specifically measures neuromuscular activity in the shoulder girdle, making it particularly relevant for athletes involved in contact sports or activities requiring overhead movements.

Bilateral Assessment

Both upper limbs are evaluated to establish dominant/non-dominant limb strength ratios, enabling data normalisation and asymmetry detection.

Positioning

Prone Alignment:

  • Subject lies face-down with forehead stabilised on a 4cm dense foam block to maintain cervical neutral.
  • Testing arm positioned on a vertically oriented force platform (e.g.force plate or hand held dynamometer).
  • Maintain pelvis neutral during the test.

Testing Procedure

Three isometric positions are assessed, each requiring maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) for 3 seconds:

I-Test (180° Abduction)

  • Shoulder: Full 180° abduction in scapular plane
  • Elbow: Full extension
  • Forearm: Pronated
  • Contralateral Limb: Neutral at side

Y-Test (135° Abduction)

  • Shoulder: 135° abduction (scapular plane elevation)
  • Elbow: Full extension
  • Forearm: Pronated
  • Contralateral Limb: Posteriorly placed behind back

T-Test (90° Abduction)

  • Shoulder: 90° abduction (frontal plane)
  • Elbow: Full extension
  • Forearm: Pronated
  • Contralateral Limb: Posteriorly placed behind back

Key Implementation Details

  • Trials: 3 attempts per position, alternating limbs
  • Rest Intervals: 20 seconds between trials, 2 minutes between positions
  • Data Capture: Peak force recorded via force platform or hand held dynamometer.
  • Normalisation: This standardised protocol allows reliable tracking of shoulder girdle neuromuscular capacity in overhead athletes, with established test-retest reliability (ICC >0.85). The prone position minimises trunk compensation while the foam block maintains cervicothoracic alignment during force production.

Closed Kinetic Chain Upper Extremity Stability Test (CKCUEST)

The CKCUEST assesses upper extremity stability, strength, and dynamic control in a closed kinetic chain position. It is commonly used in sports and rehabilitation settings to monitor progress and readiness for return to activity.

Test Setup

  • Mark two parallel lines on the floor, 36 inches (91.4 cm) apart using tape.
  • The participant assumes a push-up position with one hand on each line. Males use a standard push-up position; females and those unable to perform a full push-up may use a modified (kneeling) push-up position.
  • The back should remain flat and parallel to the floor; hands should be directly under the shoulders, perpendicular to the floor.

Test Procedure

1. Warm-Up/Familiarisation:

Allow the participant to perform a practice trial to become familiar with the movement.

2. Starting Position:

Assume the push-up (or modified push-up) position with each hand on the tape lines.

3. Movement:

On the tester’s signal (“Go”), the participant lifts one hand, reaches across the body, and touches the tape line under the opposite hand, then returns to the starting position.

Alternate hands for each touch (left hand touches right, right hand touches left), repeating this as many times as possible in 15 seconds.

4. Timing:

The test duration is 15 seconds per trial.

5. Trials:

Perform one submaximal (practice) trial, followed by three maximal effort trials, each separated by a 45-second rest period.

The final score is the average number of touches from the three maximal trials.

Scoring

  • Count each time the participant touches the tape line under the opposite hand as one touch.
  • The total number of touches in 15 seconds is the score for that trial.
  • Average the scores from the three maximal trials to obtain the final test score.

Posterior Shoulder Endurance Test (PSET)

The PSET is designed to assess the endurance of the posterior shoulder muscles, particularly the scapular stabilisers and rotator cuff, using a simple, clinically accessible method.

Test Setup

  • The participant lies prone (face down) on a treatment table, with the test arm(s) hanging off the edge.
  • The shoulder is positioned at 90° of horizontal abduction and full external rotation.
  • The elbow is fully extended, and the palms facing down.
  • The test can be performed unilaterally (one arm at a time) or bilaterally (both arms simultaneously).

Test Procedure

  1. Instruct the participant to raise their arm(s) straight out to the side, maintaining shoulder height, with no movement at the shoulder joint.
  2. The participant holds this position isometrically for as long as possible.
  3. The examiner times how long the participant can maintain the position before the arm(s) start to drop or the shoulder blades begin to lift off the table.
  4. The test ends when the participant can no longer keep the arm(s) at shoulder height or maintain proper scapular position.
  5. Repeat the test two more times and record the longest time achieved.

Scoring

  • The score is the maximum time (in seconds) the participant is able to maintain the correct position.
  • The best time out of three trials is recorded as the final score.

Notes

  • The PSET can be performed with or without a standardised external load, which may be determined based on body weight and arm length for greater precision.
  • The test is considered reliable and can distinguish between individuals with and without shoulder pain.
  • There is limited normative data, but times less than 46–47 seconds may indicate reduced endurance in those with shoulder pain.

External Rotation to Internal Rotation Ratio

Purpose:
To assess the balance between shoulder external rotator (ER) and internal rotator (IR) muscle strength, providing a ratio (ER/IR) that helps identify muscular imbalances and injury risk.

Equipment Needed

  • Hand-held dynamometer (HHD) or isokinetic dynamometer
  • Plinth or chair for seated or supine testing
  • Goniometer (optional, for standardising arm position)

Participant Position

  • Seated or supine with the shoulder in 90° abduction and elbow in 90° flexion.
  • The forearm is in neutral rotation.
  • The examiner stabilises the upper arm to prevent compensatory movement.

Test Procedure

1. Warm-Up

Allow the participant to perform a general upper limb warm-up (e.g., arm circles, light resistance exercises).

2. External Rotation (ER) Strength Test

  • Position the dynamometer just proximal to the wrist on the dorsal (back) side of the forearm.
  • Instruct the participant to push upward (external rotation) against the dynamometer with maximal effort for 3–5 seconds.
  • Record the peak force (in Newtons or kilograms).
  • Perform 2–3 trials, allowing 30–60 seconds rest between trials. Use the highest value for analysis.

3. Internal Rotation (IR) Strength Test

  • Position the dynamometer just proximal to the wrist on the volar (front) side of the forearm.
  • Instruct the participant to push downward (internal rotation) against the dynamometer with maximal effort for 3–5 seconds.
  • Record the peak force.
  • Perform 2–3 trials, allowing 30–60 seconds rest between trials. Use the highest value for analysis.

Calculation of ER/IR Ratio

ER/IR Ratio (%) = Max IR Strength / Max ER Strength ×100

Calculate the ratio for each shoulder separately.

Interpretation

Normal ER/IR ratio:

Isokinetic: 66–75% (ER is 66–75% of IR strength).
Isometric: 75–100% (depending on position).

Ratios below these ranges may indicate increased risk for shoulder injury, especially in overhead athletes.